Black Pearl export at the time involved several traverses, some more risky than others. Pearls collected at various islands were first transported to local collecting centers such as Nueva Cadiz and, after various cuts were taken, including royal fifth, most of the Black pearls were sent to large regional ports such as Santo Domingo. From the Caribbean ports of Santo Domingo, Cartagena, and Havana, vessels laden with their precious cargoes of pearls and gold sets sail for Spain, Detroit fraught with danger from several sources. Some ship was never made it back but sank at sea in then unpredictable tropical hurricanes. Other ships were preyed upon by pirates who became increasingly more numerous throughout the 16th century. Most of these were English, French, or Dutch privateers routed Earls either from attacks on ships or raids in villages. In 1592, when English pirates were spotted off the coast of Cabo Vela, “every ship and pearl fishing canoe that could get away… Sought refuge in the harbor.” One English pirates captured a Spanish vessel from Sato Domingo in 1549 and seized nine bags of pearls. The celebrated English pirates John Hawkins and Francis Drake, secretly encouraged by England’s queen Elizabeth, routinely applied the waters of the Spanish Main and seized pearls whenever they could.
Not withstanding these losses, most New World Black pearls arrived safely in Spain to be placed in the royal treasury or in the hands of private dealers. Seville became the center of Pearl market, a position in Venice had claimed in previous centuries. One sailor wrote that girls from the West in East were so abundant in Seville “that they were sold in a heat in that India House… Just as if there were some kind of seed.”
Saville even surpassed Lisbon, which, through the opening of new trade routes around the Cape of Good Hope, controlled the main Black Pearl sources in the Persian Gulf and the Gulf of Mannar. Jewelers, Pearl drillers, merchants, and investors thronged the streets of Seville. Through them, New World pearls were shipped everywhere in Europe and even to Asia.
This was the dawn of the European age of pearls pearls became an obsession among the elite, the height of fashion, and symbols of wealth and power. Without serious competition from other gems — sophisticated faceting techniques for precious stones were not developed until the mid-17th century — Black pearls were unique and unrivaled. Pearl producing areas from the New World, Persia, and India all had legends of entrepreneurs or divers who became enormously wealthy from finding a single Pearl. This gold rush mentality extended to consumers. In 16th-century Europe, and rich to buy the loot of the age of discovery, conspicuous consumption rose to unprecedented heights.
Portraits of European royalty at this time display a wealth of pearls in dress and jewelry. The portrait of Isabel de Valois, third wife of Philip of Spain, by a Lonzo Sanchez, shows her wearing large round pearls and rubies in her headdress, necklace, and else, and a long her bodice and shoulders. Black Pearls are also stitched to her caller and the top of her dress. In a portrait in Florence Catherine the queen of France in the mid-16th century, is shown with the round white pearls embroidered on her dress in addition to a Pearl headdress, necklace, and earrings. In numerous portraits of queen Elizabeth of England, and the men and women of her court, the site of pearls is overwhelming. Although some of these were probably European freshwater pearls or Marine pearls from the Persian Gulf, others were undoubtably American Black pearls, seized in the Caribbean by loyal English pirates and delivered to their revered queen.
Some of the most famous American pearls acquired their own names and histories. La Peregrina, a large pear shaped white Pearl, was collected in Panamá and acquired an astonishing history of ownership. The Charles II Pearl was found in 1691 and was said to closely match La Peregrina in size and beauty. Another Panamanian Pearl called La Huerfana or The Orphan — so named because it was found a loose in the shell beds and not in a Pearl oyster — also became part of the Spanish royal jewels. Noted for its large size, beautiful luster, and perfect shape, La Huerfana was briefly owned by Isabel de Bobadilla, daughter of the man who sent Columbus back to Spain and irons.